We are here with our selection of the top 5 best high-risk, high-reward FPL picks for the 25-27 season. Fantasy Premier League 2026/27 has already sparked endless debates over which players deserve a place in our squads. While safe picks offer consistency, it is often the high-risk, high-reward assets that separate good FPL managers from great ones.
Whether it's injury concerns, significant price increases, or a poor previous campaign, the following five players all come with major question marks. However, if everything falls into place, they could also become some of the biggest bargains of the season.
1. Alexander Isak (£9.0m)
Alexander Isak enters the new campaign at £9.0m, a substantial drop from last season's £10.5m, reflecting a disappointing year plagued by injuries and inconsistent performances.
There's no denying the risk. Isak has developed a reputation for being injury-prone, and even when available last season, he rarely looked like the lethal striker who once terrorised Premier League defences at Newcastle.
However, FPL managers know exactly what his ceiling is. A fully fit Isak is capable of scoring goals for fun, with elite movement, clinical finishing and the ability to deliver explosive double-digit hauls. If Andoni Iraola & Liverpool can get him firing again, his reduced price could make him one of the standout value forwards in the game.
2. Cole Palmer (£9.5m)
Cole Palmer is another premium asset whose price has fallen after a frustrating campaign. At £9.5m, he represents both enormous upside and considerable risk.
Last season was interrupted by injuries, and whenever Palmer returned, he struggled to reach the exceptional standards he had previously set. His creativity and goal threat were noticeably reduced, making him difficult to trust for long periods.
The biggest reason for optimism is Chelsea's new era under Xabi Alonso. If Palmer stays fit and rediscovers the form that established him as one of the Premier League's elite attacking midfielders, £9.5m could quickly look like a bargain. His ability to score, create chances and potentially take penalties gives him one of the highest ceilings among midfielders.
3. Morgan Gibbs-White (£8.0m)
Morgan Gibbs-White enjoyed a sensational campaign despite playing in a Nottingham Forest side that spent much of the season battling near the bottom of the table.
The midfielder produced an outstanding 15 goals and 4 assists, playing a massive role in Forest's survival. Naturally, FPL has responded with a hefty £2.0m price rise, taking him to £8.0m.
That increase changes the conversation completely. At his previous price, he was outstanding value. At £8.0m, expectations are significantly higher, making him a far riskier investment.
Still, there is plenty of potential for another excellent season. If Gibbs-White can continue producing similar numbers under new manager Oliver Glasner, he could once again reward patient FPL managers. The price makes him harder to justify, but the upside remains undeniable.
4. Kai Havertz (£7.5m)
At £7.5m, Kai Havertz could become one of the most intriguing forward options in FPL.
When fully fit, Havertz has firmly established himself as Mikel Arteta's first-choice striker and has consistently shown he can deliver goals in Arsenal's attack. His intelligent movement, aerial ability and link-up play make him an attractive fantasy option whenever fitness isn't an issue.
He also impressed while representing Germany at the World Cup, reminding everyone of the quality he possesses when playing with confidence.
The biggest concern is availability. Injury problems have repeatedly disrupted his momentum, preventing him from becoming a reliable long-term FPL asset. If he can finally put those fitness issues behind him, Havertz has every chance of outperforming his £7.5m price tag.
5. Yoane Wissa (£6.0m)
Perhaps the biggest surprise inclusion on this list is Yoane Wissa, who is available for just £6.0m.
Many managers will overlook him after a hugely disappointing season in which he was among the league's least effective forwards. However, there is another side to the story.
Before that difficult campaign, Wissa had already proven himself as a Premier League goalscorer with Brentford, finding the net 19 times in his final season for the club.
Now at Newcastle under new manager Matthias Jaissle, Wissa has the opportunity for a fresh start. If he can overcome his injury setbacks and rediscover the clinical form that made him such a dangerous striker, he could become one of the biggest bargain forwards in FPL this season.
Final Thoughts
Every successful FPL season involves taking calculated risks, and these five players perfectly fit that description. Injury records, price increases and recent struggles mean none of them are safe selections, but each possesses the quality to massively outperform expectations.
If Alexander Isak and Cole Palmer stay healthy, Morgan Gibbs-White justifies his new price, Kai Havertz remains fit as Arsenal's leading striker, and Yoane Wissa revives his best goalscoring form, all five have the potential to become some of the highest-reward investments in FPL 2026/27. Choosing the right one at the right time could prove decisive in climbing the overall rankings.
Also Read |
