The 2025/26 Fantasy Premier League season has seen several goalkeepers emerge as game-changing assets for managers. While premium forwards and midfielders often dominate headlines, goalkeepers have once again proven how valuable they can be in FPL through clean sheets, save points, bonus points, and overall consistency.
This season, a mix of established stars and surprise performers have climbed to the top of the goalkeeper rankings. From title-chasing clubs to newly promoted sides, these shot-stoppers have delivered massive returns for fantasy managers throughout the campaign.
Here is a look at the top five highest-scoring goalkeepers in FPL during the 2025/26 season.
5. Gianluigi Donnarumma – Manchester City (135 Points)
Italian goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma has enjoyed a strong debut Premier League campaign with Manchester City. Known for his commanding presence and elite shot-stopping ability, Donnarumma adapted quickly to English football and became a reliable fantasy option.
Despite Manchester City going through periods of inconsistency defensively, Donnarumma consistently delivered save points and bonus returns. His ability to make crucial stops in big matches helped him remain among the top-scoring keepers in the game.
FPL managers particularly benefited from his performances in tougher fixtures, where his save count often compensated even when clean sheets were not guaranteed.
4. Jordan Pickford – Everton (135 Points)
Jordan Pickford continues to prove why he remains one of the most dependable goalkeepers in Fantasy Premier League. Representing Everton, Pickford once again combined consistency with excellent shot-stopping performances.
Everton’s defensive structure allowed Pickford to collect several clean sheets throughout the campaign, while his high save volume boosted his fantasy output further. He has long been regarded as one of the best value goalkeepers in FPL, and this season reinforced that reputation.
His experience, leadership, and ability to produce big performances in difficult matches made him a favorite among managers looking for a reliable long-term goalkeeper option.
3. Robin Roefs – Sunderland (136 Points)
One of the biggest surprises of the season has been Robin Roefs of Sunderland. The young goalkeeper exceeded expectations and emerged as one of the breakout fantasy stars of the campaign.
Playing for a newly promoted side often means facing a large number of shots, and Roefs used that to his advantage in FPL. His impressive reflexes and ability to rack up save points helped him climb the rankings quickly.
What made Roefs especially valuable was his affordability compared to premium goalkeepers. Many fantasy managers viewed him as one of the best budget picks of the season due to his ability to combine save points with occasional clean sheets.
His performances have also played a major role in Sunderland’s competitive return to the Premier League.
2. Caoimhín Kelleher – Brentford (143 Points)
Caoimhín Kelleher has finally established himself as a first-choice goalkeeper following his move to Brentford, and the results have been outstanding.
Kelleher’s calmness under pressure and strong distribution fit perfectly into Brentford’s style of play. More importantly for fantasy managers, he delivered a highly consistent stream of points across the season.
With Brentford maintaining solid defensive numbers, Kelleher benefited from frequent clean sheets while also adding valuable save points and bonus returns. His performances against top opposition particularly stood out, helping him secure the second-highest goalkeeper total in FPL this season.
For many managers, Kelleher became one of the smartest transfers of the year.
1. David Raya – Arsenal (162 Points)
At the top of the rankings sits David Raya of Arsenal with an outstanding 162 FPL points.
Raya has been the clear standout goalkeeper of the 2025/26 campaign thanks to Arsenal’s exceptional defensive record and his own consistency between the posts. The Spanish goalkeeper combined clean sheets with bonus point hauls on a regular basis, making him arguably the most reliable goalkeeper in Fantasy Premier League.
Arsenal’s organized defensive setup gave Raya a strong platform, but his own performances elevated him above the competition. His composure, distribution, and crucial saves in tight matches made him essential for many top-performing FPL squads.
Managers who trusted Raya early in the season were heavily rewarded, as he consistently outscored other premium goalkeeper options throughout the campaign.
Conclusion
The 2025/26 FPL season highlighted the importance of selecting the right goalkeeper strategy. While premium picks like David Raya dominated through clean sheets and consistency, budget-friendly surprises such as Robin Roefs also delivered tremendous value.
Goalkeepers may not always attract the same attention as attacking players, but these five stars proved that strong performances between the posts can make a major difference in Fantasy Premier League success.
Also Read |
