Tottenham Hotspur suffered a disappointing 2-0 defeat to Newcastle United, with Anthony Elanga and Yoane Wissa finding the net to secure a convincing away victory for the Magpies. Spurs struggled to create enough clear-cut opportunities and were particularly poor defensively, allowing Newcastle to take control of the game for long periods. Despite a few encouraging individual performances, Tottenham lacked the quality and consistency required to trouble their opponents.
Newcastle, meanwhile, looked organised and dangerous in attack. Nicolás González produced a brilliant debut, while Amar Dedić and Lewis Hall were among the standout performers. Here are the Tottenham Hotspur vs Newcastle player ratings from the game.
Tottenham Hotspur Player Ratings vs Newcastle
Antonín Kinský – 4/10
Kinský tried his best between the posts and made a few useful interventions. However, he was let down by a poor defensive display in front of him and could do little to prevent Newcastle from scoring twice.
Micky van de Ven – 4/10
Nowhere near the performance expected from a captain. Van de Ven looked uncomfortable throughout the game and struggled to provide the leadership Spurs needed at the back.
Andrew Robertson – 5/10
One of Tottenham's better players on the day. Robertson showed more composure than most of his teammates, although his overall performance was still only average.
Pedro Porro – 5/10
Porro was another relatively bright performer for Spurs. He got forward and produced a few promising efforts, including some good shots, but could not influence the result.
Jan Paul van Hecke – 4/10
It has been a difficult start to life at Spurs for Van Hecke. He looked very poor defensively and struggled to deal with Newcastle's attacking movement.
Mateus Fernandes – 4/10
Fernandes tried to make things happen in midfield but ultimately failed to produce enough quality in the final third or make a significant difference to Tottenham's performance.
Archie Gray – 4/10
An average outing from Gray. He worked hard but was unable to impose himself on the game or provide the control Spurs needed.
Rodrigo Bentancur – 4/10
Bentancur was simply a normal presence in midfield. He offered little in terms of creativity or defensive influence and made no major contribution.
Sandro Tonali – 3/10
Another anonymous performance from Tonali. Following his record transfer, expectations are understandably high, and he needs to step up quickly.
Mathys Tel – 2/10
A shockingly poor performance from Tel. He offered very little going forward and his display could raise questions about whether he deserves to remain in the starting lineup.
Omar Marmoush – 6/10
Marmoush was Tottenham's most lively forward. He constantly looked willing to attack, but his lack of clinical finishing ultimately prevented him from turning his efforts into a goal.
Substitutes
Destiny Udogie – 4/10: Had no real effect after coming off the bench.
Dominic Solanke – 3/10: Another poor outing from a player whose Spurs career has been abysmal so far.
Mohamed Kudus – 4/10: A forgettable appearance after coming on.
Mikey Moore – 4/10: The youngster failed to make a meaningful impact.
Newcastle United Player Ratings vs Tottenham
Lukáš Horníček – 7/10
Made a few decent saves and played an important role in helping Newcastle secure a clean sheet.
Lewis Hall – 8/10
Simply phenomenal, particularly in attack. Hall repeatedly found dangerous positions and was one of Newcastle's most impressive players.
Sven Botman – 7/10
Provided leadership and stability at the back, helping Newcastle keep Tottenham under control.
Amar Dedić – 9/10
A superb start to his Premier League career. Dedić was aggressive going forward and capped his display with an assist for Elanga's goal.
Malick Thiaw – 7/10
Aggressive and solid defensively, Thiaw helped Newcastle maintain their defensive shape.
Lewis Miley – 6/10
An energetic and decent performance from Miley, who worked hard throughout the game.
Joe Willock – 6/10
Helped Newcastle control the midfield and maintain their grip on the match.
Nicolás González – 8.5/10
A brilliant debut. González produced the outstanding long-range pass that created the opening goal and immediately showcased his quality.
Anthony Elanga – 8/10
Elanga continues to be in terrific form. After scoring in his previous game, he found the net again here to give Newcastle the breakthrough.
Yoane Wissa – 8/10
Wissa looks reborn and is finally showing his best form after an injury-affected 2025/26 season. His goal capped another excellent display.
Harvey Barnes – 7/10
A solid, if unspectacular, performance from Barnes as Newcastle comfortably managed the game.
Substitutes
Sean Steur – 6/10: A decent performance from the bench.
Jacob Murphy – 5/10: Another routine substitute appearance.
Nick Woltemade – 7/10: Made a valuable contribution by assisting the crucial second goal.
Jacob Ramsey – 5/10: A normal performance after coming off the bench.
Bazoumana Touré – NR: Came on too late to be fairly rated.
Conclusion
Newcastle will be delighted with their performance and the manner in which they controlled Tottenham, while Spurs have plenty to improve after a disappointing showing. Tottenham will next travel to face Nottingham Forest away, while Newcastle United will host Bournemouth in their next Premier League fixture.
